UC Berkeley architecture students demand professor’s removal amid sex misconduct allegations

alsayyad_joshuajordan_file
Joshua Jordan/File

Related Posts

Students and alumni of the campus architecture department created a petition in January to remove architecture professor Nezar AlSayyad’s tenure after he was found to have sexually harassed a campus graduate student.

Eva Hagberg Fisher, a former doctoral student in the campus architecture program, filed a complaint with the Title IX office in March 2016 against AlSayyad, alleging that he regularly hugged her, invited her for drinks or dinner and gave unsolicited compliments on her appearance while she was studying under him.

Fisher alleged that AlSayyad put his hand on her upper thigh and asked if the two of them could become “close friends.” Following Fisher’s complaint, an independent investigation commissioned by UC Berkeley in 2016 found AlSayyad to be in violation of the Faculty Code of Conduct. News of the investigation’s findings were made public by the San Francisco Chronicle in November 2016.

AlSayyad denied the allegations outlined in the petition.

“I have not violated any code of conduct, nor has the university administration — to my knowledge — found that I have violated any university code of conduct at this time,” AlSayyad alleged.

alsayyad_mug

Though AlSayyad is not currently teaching, he still advises students and earns more than $200,000 a year, according to campus doctoral student Eric Peterson, who helped create the petition. Fisher said a campus official told her in November 2017 that disciplinary action might be determined by early January.

Campus spokesperson Janet Gilmore said in an email that “policies and confidentiality requirements” prevent the campus from disclosing case information, including whether or not a case exists, until the full process has been completed. Gilmore added that when it comes to cases of sexual misconduct the campus typically responds “directly to the students” and address their “general concerns.“

“There have been several cases of sexual harassment on this campus for the past several years,” Peterson said. “It seems that administration is not going to take any action until students put them in a position where they have to.”

Campus alumna Marianela D’Aprile, who helped create the petition along with Peterson, said AlSayyad’s behaviors were an “open secret” in the architecture department, even before Fisher filed her complaint. According to D’Aprile, rumors — which were corroborated by the 2016 investigation — of AlSayyad’s “inappropriate relationships with his students” and “manipulative” treatment had already begun to circulate.

Peterson said, however, that the campus never disclosed information about the investigation, Fisher’s complaint or AlSayyad’s status. He added that the process has “failed” students, and many would never have known of AlSayyad’s alleged harassment if Fisher had not made the reports public by giving them to the San Francisco Chronicle.

“(Professor and chair of architecture) Tom Buresh knew this stuff was happening and ignored it,” Fisher alleged. “I would like the administrators who knew — who had received reports about this person decades ago — … to be held accountable.”

D’Aprile said the fact that AlSayyad still hasn’t been met with “disciplinary action” — nearly two years after Fisher’s initial complaint — indicates that the way the campus deals with sexual harassment cases is “broken and needs to be fixed.”

“Ultimately I want the university to realize it is more expensive not to deal with these things than it is to be proactive,” Fisher said. “I could’ve not had to suffer and not had a full-time job of essentially trying to drag the university if I could’ve just had a response — if they could have treated me like a human being.”

Anjali Shrivastava covers academics and administration. Contact her at [email protected] and follow her on Twitter at @anjalii_shrivas.

Clarification(s):
A previous version of this article may have implied that campus spokesperson Janet Gilmore commented on a case involving AlSayyad. In fact, Gilmore said she cannot comment on any case, including whether or not a case exists, until the full process has been completed.

Correction(s):
A previous version of this article incorrectly stated that Eva Hagberg Fisher is a former doctoral candidate in the campus architecture program. In fact, she is a former doctoral student.

Please keep our community civil. Comments should remain on topic and be respectful.
Read our full comment policy
  • SamXie

    Eva is not the only one. We all know that.

  • jcdenton2012

    I will be honest. I don’t know anything about Mr. AlSayyad as to determine the credibility of the charges against him. However, I did do some research on him in terms of how he is as a teacher. There is a term for people like him. He’s a “hard-ass.” Knowledgeable, insightful, but he expects you to ‘get it’ and doesn’t like repeating himself if you don’t ‘get it.’ He also tests hard, and that was one of the main complaints from “Rate My Professor.”

    • SMH

      jcdenton2012: “He’s [AlSayyad] a “hard-ass.”

      You mean an ass-hole.

      “Knowledgeable, insightful…”

      At least that’s what AlSayyad pretends to be. What was his specific academic qualifications (like history, or anthropology, or political science, or sociology, or literature) to once have been chair of CMES (the Center for Middle Eastern Studies)?

      Obviously Nezar AlSayyad wasn’t “knowledgeable & insightful” enough to know when he was sexually harassing/tormenting and emotionally abusing/brutalizing women students and when they didn’t want his sexual attention/abuse.

      But, I guess he was “knowledgeable” about conniving and try to be controlling.
      .

  • SMH

    .

    Nezar AlSayyad always was at least somewhat of a controlling scummbag.

    So I’m not surprised at all.

    He’s finally getting what he’s had coming to him.

    I once told him what I thought about him to his face!

    .

    • California Defender

      What did you say to him?

      • SMH

        Plenty enough for him to get the point.

        • SMH

          And there was even a former director of I-House (and married professor) who thought/thinks that female university students and at least one former subordinate student worker at I-House (whom he had cornered and propositioned with a totally lame ‘come-on’ right on the job) were/are his potential dating pool.