daily californian logo

BERKELEY'S NEWS • NOVEMBER 27, 2022

Take a look at our 2022 midterm elections special issue!

Federal judge dismisses lawsuit against Berkeley marijuana dispensary

article image

SONIA BRIN | FILE

SUPPORT OUR NONPROFIT NEWSROOM

We're an independent student-run newspaper, and need your support to maintain our coverage.

NOVEMBER 02, 2016

A judge dismissed a forfeiture action against Berkeley Patients Group on Tuesday, ending a three-year legal challenge by the federal government to shut down the city’s oldest marijuana dispensary.

In May 2013, then-U.S. attorney for the Northern District of California Melinda Haag filed a lawsuit against Nahla Droubi, the landlord of the property where the dispensary operates, threatening to confiscate the land because it is within 1,000 feet of two preschools a violation of federal law but not California law.

According to UC Berkeley law professor Robert Berring, Jr., the lawsuit came as part of a series of tactics by the federal government to hinder marijuana dispensaries’ operation.

“The strange thing was that they chose to go after Berkeley Patients Group, a dispensary which really has been really aboveboard and tried to follow Berkeley’s rules,” Berring said.

After the lawsuit was filed, Berkeley Patients Group and the city — which collects the dispensary’s tax revenues and regulates medical marijuana in Berkeley joined the litigation process, according to Drug Policy Alliance senior staff attorney Lindsay LaSalle, who represented the city in the case.

Despite the ongoing lawsuit, a district judge ruled in February 2015 that Berkeley Patients Group could continue its operations while the case progressed.

In early October of this year, the U.S. Attorney’s Office and claimants of the case began to discuss a dismissal with prejudicemeaning the dispensary cannot be prosecuted again for the same claims — according to Henry Wykowski, counsel for Berkeley Patients Group.

But on Oct. 21, the U.S. Attorney’s Office filed a dismissal without prejudice to the court and without prior warning to the dispensary, Wykowski said. Berkeley Patients Group filed an objection, and the U.S. Attorney’s Office agreed this week to a dismissal with prejudice so long as the dispensary does not sue the U.S. Department of Justice for initiating the lawsuit.

The case against Berkeley Patients Group is the last of four federal lawsuits against Bay Area dispensaries resolved in the past two years.

A federal appeals court in August upheld a current budget amendment stating that federal funds may not be used to prosecute marijuana dispensaries that comply with state laws. The distribution and production of marijuana — even for medicinal purposes — is still prohibited under federal law.

Because it is a federal crime, should the federal budget amendment not be renewed in the future, Berkeley Patients Group could have been sued again unless a dismissal with prejudice was granted, Wykowski said.

“I would say that this deal is a signal that things are going to get better,” Berring said. “We’re going to vote next Tuesday, and (the) state of California may well legalize marijuana. … It seems to be a bipartisan recognition that the law just makes no sense right now.”

The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of California declined to comment on the case.

Contact Charlene Jin at [email protected] and follow her on Twitter at @CharleneJin0327.
LAST UPDATED

NOVEMBER 03, 2016


Related Articles

featured article
After almost three hours of presentations and public comment at its full-capacity Tuesday regular meeting, Berkeley City Council voted to award permits to Berkeley Compassionate Care Center and The Apothecarium that will allow them to operate medical marijuana dispensaries in the city.
After almost three hours of presentations and public comment at its full-capacity Tuesday regular meeting, Berkeley City Council voted to award permits to Berkeley Compassionate Care Center and The Apothecarium that will allow them to operate medical marijuana dispensaries in the city.
featured article
featured article
Berkeley City Council will discuss selecting two more medical marijuana dispensaries in Berkeley and approving a plan that would gradually increase the general fund reserve at its regular Tuesday meeting, with a special meeting beforehand on the midyear crime report with the Berkeley Police Department.
Berkeley City Council will discuss selecting two more medical marijuana dispensaries in Berkeley and approving a plan that would gradually increase the general fund reserve at its regular Tuesday meeting, with a special meeting beforehand on the midyear crime report with the Berkeley Police Department.
featured article
featured article
The Berkeley Planning Commission met Wednesday evening to discuss an amendment that would raise the number of legally allowed medical marijuana dispensaries in the city from four to six.
The Berkeley Planning Commission met Wednesday evening to discuss an amendment that would raise the number of legally allowed medical marijuana dispensaries in the city from four to six.
featured article