daily californian logo

BERKELEY'S NEWS • SEPTEMBER 26, 2023

Apply to The Daily Californian by September 8th!

40 Berkeley Law professors sign letter to Senate opposing Kavanaugh’s confirmation

article image

WIKIMEDIA | CREATIVE COMMONS

SUPPORT OUR NONPROFIT NEWSROOM

We're an independent student-run newspaper, and need your support to maintain our coverage.

OCTOBER 04, 2018

As of press time, about 40 UC Berkeley School of Law professors have signed a letter presented to the United States Senate on Thursday that argues Judge Brett Kavanaugh should not be confirmed to the Supreme Court.

The letter, published in the New York Times opinion section, includes signatures from more than 2,400 law professors from across the country as of press time. The Senate is currently reviewing the FBI’s report that investigated sexual misconduct allegations against Kavanaugh — it will begin voting on whether to confirm Kavanaugh on Friday.

While the law professors have differing views about Kavanaugh’s other qualifications, the letter said they are “united” in believing that during the Senate hearings Sept. 27, Kavanaugh did not display the “impartiality and judicial temperament” necessary to sit on the Supreme Court.

I was very dismayed by the hearings and Kavanaugh’s demeanor,” said law school Dean Erwin Chemerinsky, who signed the letter, in an email. “My hope is that the letter will help persuade Senators to vote no on Kavanaugh’s confirmation.”

Chemerinsky said in a press release that he signed the letter “without hesitation” and that he thinks Kavanaugh lied many times during the hearing. He added that if Kavanaugh is confirmed, there will always be a “cloud over his confirmation” that will tarnish the Supreme Court.

The letter intends to appeal to about five senators whose vote may be swayed, according to Berkeley Law professor Christopher Kutz, who also signed the letter. He said Kavanaugh’s behavior is “not even remotely close” to what should be expected from any judge, let alone a Supreme Court justice.

“Regardless of a jurist’s legal views, a justice has to weigh issues and act fairly, rationally and respectfully,” said Berkeley Law professor Charles Weisselberg, who signed the letter, in an email. “I can understand that he is upset that claims against him have surfaced. Yet, for me, his performance was disqualifying.”

Berkeley Law students, as well as professors, have been responding to the Kavanaugh hearings.

Berkeley Law student Benjamin Phillips said he is “really appreciative” that Chemerinsky signed the letter, adding that he was “disturbed” by Kavanaugh’s response to the sexual misconduct allegations and that Kavanaugh’s partisan attacks will “degrade the credibility” of the Supreme Court.

The Kavanaugh hearings have been discussed at least once in all of Berkeley Law student Savelle Jefferson’s classes, he said. While Jefferson said he doubts the letter will have an effect on the confirmation process, he agrees that Kavanaugh lacked professionalism during the hearing.

Regardless of what you think about the underlying allegations of sexual misconduct, he has demonstrated that he will not be candid and truthful in testimony,” Kutz said. “The display of rage and extreme partisan tone of his language makes him untrustworthy as Supreme Court Justice.”

Contact Jenny Weng at [email protected] and follow her on Twitter at @jennyweng1999.
LAST UPDATED

OCTOBER 05, 2018


Related Articles

featured article
Four Californians — including former Berkeley Top Dog employee Cole White — have been arrested for their alleged violent participation in the Charlottesville “Unite the Right" rally of August 2017.
Four Californians — including former Berkeley Top Dog employee Cole White — have been arrested for their alleged violent participation in the Charlottesville “Unite the Right" rally of August 2017.
featured article
featured article
The new rules, made public by The New York Times on Wednesday, would extend beyond federal guidance for college sexual misconduct cases to include a narrower definition of sexual harassment and the steps campuses are legally required to take to address it.
The new rules, made public by The New York Times on Wednesday, would extend beyond federal guidance for college sexual misconduct cases to include a narrower definition of sexual harassment and the steps campuses are legally required to take to address it.
featured article
featured article
Lee will be running against the current vice chair, U.S. Rep. Linda Sánchez, D-California, who announced her bid on July 17.
Lee will be running against the current vice chair, U.S. Rep. Linda Sánchez, D-California, who announced her bid on July 17.
featured article