We're an independent, student-run newsroom.

As an independent student newspaper and the paper of record for the city of Berkeley, the Daily Cal has been communicating important updates during this pandemic. Your support is essential to maintaining this coverage.

donate here

Berkeley's News | The Daily Californian

Tuesday, January 19, 2021

News

  • News
    • Campus
    • City
    • County
    • UC
    • State
    • National
    • ASUC
    • Obituaries
    • Research & Ideas
    • Elections 2020
    • COVID-19
    • Notes from the Field
  • Sports
    • Football
    • M. Hoops
    • W. Hoops
    • Baseball
    • Rugby
    • M. Soccer
    • W. Soccer
    • Volleyball
    • Softball
    • M. Tennis
    • W. Tennis
    • M. Swim
    • W. Swim
    • Track & Field
    • Cross Country
  • Arts
    • Music
    • Film & Television
    • Fashion
    • Theater
    • Visual Art
    • Video Games
    • Comedy
    • Literature
    • Voices
    • Best of Berkeley
    • Columns
    • Local Event
    • Culture Shot
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Op-Eds
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Columns
    • The Soapbox
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • Submit a Letter to the Editor
    • Submit an Op-Ed
    • Podcasts
  • Blogs
    • Daily Clog
    • Eating Berkeley
    • Travel
    • Strikeout
    • Photo
  • Multimedia
    • Photo Essays
    • Insider
    • News: City
    • News: Campus
    • Arts
    • Culture
    • Entertainment
    • Sports
    • Podcasts
    • Projects
    • Archives
  • Weekender
  • Featured
  • About
  • Sponsorships
  • Apply
  • Classifieds
  • Advertise

Campus

Monday, November 18, 2019

‘Medicare for All’ debate discusses future, current state of US health care

Lisi Ludwig/Staff

By Kaleo Mark | Senior Staff

Last Updated November 18, 2019
Tweet Comment0

Related Posts

Cal Dems, Berkeley Conservative Society debate taxation, wages
Illustration of closed Alta Bates Closing Alta Bates threatens emergency care in Berkeley
Berkeley Conservative Society attempts to foster civil discourse in debate with Cal Berkeley Democrats

The Berkeley Conservative Society and the campus Center on Civility & Democratic Engagement hosted a “Medicare for All” debate Thursday afternoon.

About 100 people, ranging from undergraduates to senior citizens, packed into the event in Wheeler Hall. Celine Bookin, president and founder of the Berkeley Conservative Society, said in an email it is important to have the debate on Medicare for All because it is a “relevant and controversial topic.” Chancellor Carol Christ was in attendance, opening the event by reaffirming the importance of civil discourse.

“There are many, many issues which people of integrity and goodwill disagree on,” Christ said during the debate. “We are in a very difficult time in our country right now where we’re finding it more and more difficult to have reasoned discourse, to be able to talk about ideas … and to be able to work through the differences of opinions we have to solutions. That kind of reasoned discourse is absolutely essential (and) central to the university.”

Under a Medicare for All system, the government would be the sole insurer of health care, raising money through taxes and eliminating much of the private insurance market. Medicare for All would be a universal program, meaning that all Americans would be covered under the system.

Richard Scheffler, a UC Berkeley School of Public Health graduate school professor, argued in favor of Medicare for All, while Sally Pipes, president and CEO of the Pacific Research Institute, argued against it.

Scheffler said in his opening remarks that the current health care system is a “patchwork” that requires unnecessary paperwork and costs, adding that “the cost of health care is outrageous.” He said the U.S. private health insurance industry made $38 billion last year.

Pipes retorted that other countries with systems like Medicare for All, such as Canada and the United Kingdom, face doctor shortages, protracted wait times for care and increased taxes on the middle class. Pipes said the United States is “great” because of choice, and the best way to achieve universal coverage would be through “universal choice.”

“Government doesn’t create jobs,” Pipes said during the debate. “People that are innovative and entrepreneurial will create jobs in this country, so let’s keep the market working.”

Near the end of the debate, Scheffler said the country could save money through Medicare for All. He added that many studies do not take into account the “waste” and expense of the current system.

In his closing remarks, Scheffler reminded the audience that similar debates have taken place before.  

“This same discussion that Sally and I are having right now happened in 1965 when we tried to pass the Medicare bill. It was too expensive. We couldn’t afford it. The taxes would be too big. But basically, we did it,” Scheffler said during the debate. “Providing health care is a human right, not an option for the marketplace.”

Contact Kaleo Mark at [email protected] and follow him on Twitter at @kaleomark_dc.

Tags Berkeley Conservative Society, Carol Christ, Celine Bookin, Center on Civility & Democratic Engagement, Pacific Research Institute, Richard Scheffler, Sally Pipes
The Daily Californian
  • Most Popular
  • Most Recent
  1. Image of Berkeley High
    State
    CA Gov. Gavin Newsom launches online hub for information about reopening schools
  2. Army Spc. Angel Laureano holds a vial of the COVID-19 vaccine
    City
    Berkeley administers 92% of allocated vaccines, exceeds statewide distribution
  3. Image of restaurant
    Local Businesses
    Vietnamese Eatery Bánh Mì & Rolls Factory opens on Northside
  4. Image of Amperland Cast
    Film & Television
    Pinegrove sings in primary colors with absurdist music film ‘Amperland, NY’
  5. Image of campus
    UC
    UC awards $19M in grants, funds 4 UC Berkeley projects
  6. Image of deer
    Research & Ideas
    UC Berkeley researchers find fences in Wyoming impact deer migration
  7. Photo of Berkeley Lab
    Research & Ideas
    UC Berkeley, Berkeley Lab researchers create structural map of COVID-19 protein
  1. Photo of Randy Katz
    Campus
    Randy Katz to step down as vice chancellor for research
  2. Photo of Berkeley African American Studies grant
    Campus
    UC Berkeley’s African American studies department receives $2.8M grant
  3. Photo of Joseph Myers
    Obituary
    UC Berkeley professor, activist Joseph Myers dies at age 80
  4. Photo of Memorial Stadium
    Football
    Cal reels in commitment from 4-star quarterback Justyn Martin
  5. Image of Girls Volleyball
    Volleyball
    ‘Control the controllables’: The current freshman student-athlete experience
  6. Image of Amperland Cast
    Film & Television
    Pinegrove sings in primary colors with absurdist music film ‘Amperland, NY’
  7. Image of Cherry Blossoms
    The Daily Clog
    Why spring semester is objectively better than fall
  • News
    • ASUC
    • Campus
    • City
    • Crime & Courts
    • Obituary
    • Research & Ideas
    • State
    • UC
    • Notes from the Field
  • Sports
    • Men’s
      • Baseball
      • Basketball
      • Crew
      • Cross Country
      • Football
      • Golf
      • Gymnastics
      • Rugby
      • Swim
      • Tennis
      • Water Polo
    • Women’s
      • Basketball
      • Field Hockey
      • Golf
      • Gymnastics
      • Lacrosse
      • Softball
      • Swim
      • Tennis
      • Track & Field
      • Volleyball
      • Water Polo
  • A&E
    • Columns
    • Film & Television
    • Literature
    • Music
    • Theater
    • Visual Art
    • Comedy
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Op-Eds
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Columns
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • The Soapbox
    • Sex on Tuesday
    • Cal in Color
  • Multimedia
    • Arts
    • Blog
    • News: Campus
    • Sports
  • Featured
    • Editor’s Picks
    • Awards
    • Special Issues
    • The Weekender
    • Gameday
    • Best of Berkeley
    • Daily Cal Archive
    • Editors’ Blog
  • Blogs
    • The Daily Clog
    • Eating Berkeley
    • Travel
    • A&E
    • Bear Bytes
    • Strikeout
Donate We're an independent, student-run newsroom. Make a donation to support our coverage.

Copyright © 2021 The Daily Californian, The Independent Berkeley Student Publishing Co., Inc. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy. Use desktop site by default. Mobile site.