daily californian logo

BERKELEY'S NEWS • NOVEMBER 27, 2022

Take a look at our 2022 midterm elections special issue!

‘We need to act fast’: Berkeley residents discuss electrification

article image

PAUL KRUEGER | COURTESY

During a community meeting Thursday, Berkeley residents discussed the city's plans to convert from gas appliances to electric alternatives. (Photo by PaulKrueger under CC BY-SA 2.0.)

SUPPORT OUR NONPROFIT NEWSROOM

We're an independent student-run newspaper, and need your support to maintain our coverage.

|

Deputy News Editor

MAY 06, 2021

Berkeley residents voiced their opinions and concerns about the city’s plans to transition all buildings in Berkeley away from natural gas appliances to electric alternatives during a community meeting Tuesday.

The meeting began with a presentation outlining the various benefits of electrification, as well as an overview of the city’s recently released Draft Berkeley Existing Buildings Electrification Strategy. The strategy proposes a three-phased approach aiming to electrify buildings as soon as possible and no later than 2027 to 2045.

Building electrification would usually require switching out four main gas-powered appliances for electric alternatives: gas furnaces with air-source heat pumps, gas water heaters with heat pump water heaters, gas stovetops with induction ranges and gas clothes dryers with either electric resistance or heat pump clothes dryers.

“Electrification is decarbonization, said Amy Kiser, a co-chair of the Berkeley Climate Action Coalition’s electrification working group, during the meeting. “By switching from natural gas to clean electricity from solar and wind, we’re getting carbon and greenhouse gas emissions out of our buildings.”

According to Kiser, when burned, natural gas releases carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxide, increasing the risk of asthma and other health problems. She cited a study that found that children in homes with gas stoves have a 42% higher chance of developing asthma. Without proper ventilation, Kiser added, carbon monoxide can even have deadly consequences.

Kiser noted that electrification is also a step toward tackling climate change, which directly impacts communities of color — communities most affected by asthma hospitalizations in the city.

“We know there’s an ongoing housing and affordability and gentrification crisis in Berkeley,” said Denaya Shorter, the community engagement program director at the Ecology Center in Berkeley, during the meeting.

Shorter, who helped develop Berkeley’s electrification strategy, said the team took into account Berkeley’s historically discriminatory housing policies that affect low-income families of color and intentionally solicited feedback from marginalized communities.

Shorter’s team found that upfront and long-term costs are a significant concern for members of these communities and responded by developing four draft “equity guardrails” meant to ensure electrification policies would only advance if they could be implemented equitably, she added.

“We need to act fast to reduce greenhouse gas emissions,” Kiser said during the meeting. “Right now, gas is cheaper than electricity. But that’s not going to last for very long at all, because as more buildings electrify, there’ll be fewer customers to pay for the gas infrastructure.”

Katie Van Dyke, city climate action program manager, noted the importance of having a clear strategic approach to decommissioning natural gas infrastructure on a neighborhood scale.

She said it would both send a market signal and prevent the city from being left with infrastructure that is no longer valuable, also known as stranded assets. Electrifying homes “here and there” still means the utility will need to continue to serve the entire neighborhood, Van Dyke added.

Anna Kom, a Berkeley resident, said she was excited about not contributing to global warming but also concerned about public safety power shut-offs.

Deborah Moore, a city resident, said she felt the electrification process was “very piecemeal,” adding that without outside help, it was difficult to figure out what steps to take.

“It’s pretty horrifying that this report and discussion can consume so much time and treasure and not even identify the scope of the problem, or how gas network pruning is supposed to be planned,” said city resident Thomas Lord in the Zoom chat. “The city of Berkeley is asleep at the wheel.”

Contact Iris Kwok at [email protected] and follow her on Twitter at @iriskkwok.
LAST UPDATED

MAY 06, 2021


Related Articles

featured article
The U.S. power sector is halfway to zero carbon emissions, according to a Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, or Berkeley Lab, report published earlier this month.
The U.S. power sector is halfway to zero carbon emissions, according to a Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, or Berkeley Lab, report published earlier this month.
featured article
featured article
A city of Berkeley press release urged Berkeley residents to opt in to a 100% renewable electricity plan, as the city recently did. 
A city of Berkeley press release urged Berkeley residents to opt in to a 100% renewable electricity plan, as the city recently did. 
featured article
featured article
Commercial trucking is capable of undergoing major electrification, a recent study from Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory found.
Commercial trucking is capable of undergoing major electrification, a recent study from Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory found.
featured article